Should I choose YouTube memberships or Patreon?

Use YouTube memberships first (easier signup, larger audience). Add Patreon for members wanting deeper engagement, Discord access, or more customization.

Which platform pays creators more?

YouTube takes 30%, Patreon takes 8-10%. But YouTube drives more total memberships due to integration, often resulting in higher total revenue.

Can members support me on both platforms?

Yes. Some members use YouTube memberships for casual support; superfans upgrade to Patreon for exclusive community access.

Do I need Patreon if I use YouTube memberships?

No, but Patreon adds community tools YouTube lacks (messaging, Discord, extra customization). Many creators find both profitable together.

Which platform is easier to start with?

YouTube memberships—no external signup required. Patreon requires audience members to leave YouTube and create an account.

Guide

youtube-membershipspatreonplatform-comparisonmonetization

YouTube Memberships vs Patreon: Which Platform Wins in 2026?

Both platforms offer recurring revenue. Discover the pros and cons of each to choose what fits your audience and content strategy.

Last updated: March 4, 2026

Step-by-Step Guide

Assess Your Audience

Start with YouTube Memberships

Promote Patreon as Premium

Sync Perks Across Platforms

Track Revenue by Source

YouTube Memberships Advantages

YouTube memberships integrate directly into your channel, require no external link clicks, and YouTube handles all billing. Members access perks instantly and YouTube keeps discoverability within the platform.

Patreon Advantages

Patreon offers more customization, better community tools (messaging, Discord integration), and lower revenue share (8% vs YouTube's 30%). Patreon works better for non-video creators or those wanting full control.

YouTube Membership Disadvantages

YouTube takes 30%, limits customization, and requires 1,000+ subscribers. Less direct member communication and fewer bonus features compared to Patreon.

The Best Strategy

Many creators use both. YouTube memberships drive casual fans and casual spending; Patreon captures serious supporters willing to join external platforms. Combined, they maximize recurring revenue.

Pro Tips

YouTube memberships convert better for casual supporters (10x easier to join).
Patreon works best for creators with small but dedicated audiences (100+ superfans).
Offer Discord access on Patreon—YouTube memberships lack real-time community.
Price Patreon tiers 10-20% higher since they require external signup.
Use both: YouTube for volume, Patreon for superfans and community depth.