Guide
Us vs ThemInsurance Agenciesvideo adsAI videoInsurance Video Ad Template: Us vs Them [2 Min AI]
The Us vs Them format is one of the highest-performing video ad types for Insurance Agencies — and for good reason. Insurance is a distrust-heavy category — video that humanises the advisor and explains benefits plainly outperforms all other formats. FluxNote lets you create a professional Us vs Them ad for your insurance business in under 2 minutes: no camera, no editor, no design team required.
Why Us vs Them ads win market share for insurance businesses
The Us vs Them format is one of the most direct-response ad formats available to insurance businesses because it forces direct comparison and makes your value proposition undeniable. Rather than hoping prospects will figure out why you're better, you show them exactly where you win.
For homeowners, families, and small business owners who are actively comparing options, this format cuts through the noise.
When they're already considering your service alongside competitors or alternatives (DIY, bigger agencies, cheaper options), an ad that clearly addresses the comparison helps them make a decision. Decision-stage buyers convert at 5-10x the rate of awareness-stage buyers — and this format is precision-targeted at decision-stage audiences.
Done well, Us vs Them ads are not disparaging — they're clarifying.
The most effective versions compare outcomes, process quality, and value rather than attacking competitors personally.
For insurance, framing the comparison as "us vs. the generic approach" or "us vs. what most homeowners, families, and small business owners settle for" positions you as the premium option without naming competitors.
What to include in your insurance Us vs Them ad
A fair comparison baseline
Don't compare your best to their worst. The most credible comparisons use standard industry practices as the "them" — not a straw man.
3-5 comparison dimensions
Pick the dimensions where you genuinely win. Results, process quality, communication, expertise level, and client experience are strong comparison dimensions for insurance.
Specific evidence on your side
Every claim you make about yourself should have a supporting detail — a number, a credential, a process, or a result.
Acknowledgement that the other option has a place
"If budget is your primary constraint, [alternative] might work for you. But if you care about [key outcome], here's what's different about our approach." This honesty builds credibility.
A decisive CTA
"See the difference yourself — start with a free comparison call" or "Get our approach, not the generic one."
3 FluxNote prompts for insurance us vs them ads
Prompt 1
"Us vs Them comparison ad for insurance. Compare: Working with [us/our approach] vs. [generic alternative/DIY/budget option]. 3 key differences: [Dimension 1 — we win because...], [Dimension 2 — we win because...], [Dimension 3 — we win because...]. CTA: Choose the approach that gets [specific result]."
Prompt 2
"Competitive positioning ad for insurance targeting homeowners, families, and small business owners who are comparing options. Message: 'Most insurance businesses offer [generic approach]. Here's what we do differently: [3 specific differentiators].' Frame as: our clients get [specific result] vs. industry average of [lower benchmark]. CTA: Book a free comparison call."
Prompt 3
"Value comparison ad for insurance. Cost of the generic option: $[price] → Result: [average outcome]. Cost of our approach: $[price] → Result: [your typical outcome]. ROI comparison: [calculate the difference]. Frame: 'The question isn't cost — it's value per dollar.' CTA: See the math for your situation — free 15-min call."
Create your first video ad — free
15 proven formats. No filming. No editor. Done in 2 minutes.
Create Videos With AI
50,000+ creators already generating videos with FluxNote
★★★★★ 4.9 rating
Turn this into a video — in 2 minutes
FluxNote turns any idea into a publish-ready short-form video. Script, voiceover, captions, footage & music — all AI, no editing.
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes the Us vs Them format effective for Insurance Agencies?
The Us vs Them format works for Insurance Agencies because it positions your offer against the alternative — competitor, DIY, or doing nothing. It's direct-response at its most effective, validating why your solution wins. For homeowners, families, and small business owners, this directly addresses the core conversion barrier — which is why it consistently outperforms generic promotional content in this category.
Which platforms work best for Insurance Agencies us vs them ads?
Insurance Agencies businesses see the best results running us vs them ads on Facebook and LinkedIn. These platforms offer the targeting options needed to reach homeowners, families, and small business owners at scale, and their algorithm rewards the high engagement rates this format generates.
How long should a Us vs Them video ad be for Insurance Agencies?
For Insurance Agencies, the optimal us vs them ad length is 15-25 seconds for social media placements and 25-45 seconds for YouTube pre-roll. Shorter formats work well on TikTok and Instagram Reels where attention is premium, while slightly longer formats perform on Facebook and LinkedIn where homeowners, families, and small business owners are in a more researching mindset.